Your Money > Your Home
Malls: Death of an American icon
The shopping mall is headed the way of the drive-in movie and the eight-track. What's replacing it?
July 4, 2003: 1:04 PM EDT
By Sarah Max, CNN/Money Staff Writer

NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - If you spent your formative years at the local shopping mall sipping Orange Julius and hanging out near the ubiquitous water fountain, you might be sad to learn that the mall as you know it is headed toward extinction.

Even former mall rats seem to think there are better ways to spend a weekend than wandering through the windowless vestibules of a non-descript mall, shopping in tired department stores and eating food court fare.

Before: When it opened in 1966 Villa Italia was ahead of its times. It's now being rebuilt as Belmar.  
Before: When it opened in 1966 Villa Italia was ahead of its times. It's now being rebuilt as Belmar.

After turning our backs on Main Street and fleeing to the suburbs, Americans are looking for a sense of place. We're fixing up houses in the older parts of town and spending more of our free time in newly-revived downtowns. And when we want to do serious shopping, we head to upscale mega-malls and big-box stores such as Costco, Home Depot and Target, even if it means driving a little farther.

That leaves smaller neighborhood malls -- many of which are carbon copies of each other -- struggling to keep retailers from packing up and following the crowds to downtown districts or mega malls. Although some have managed to turn themselves around by looking beyond Sears and J.C. Penney and bringing in the likes of Ikea or Borders as anchors, more drastic measures are often needed. (There's even a Web site,, dedicated to tracking these doomed malls.)

After: Belmar will be more than just a mall when it opens next year.  
After: Belmar will be more than just a mall when it opens next year.

So cities and developers have begun breaking up old malls, turning their inner corridors into streets, bringing the storefronts outdoors and integrating them with the rest of the city.

"Because they're often small, older malls can't provide the same options for consumers," said Bill Anderson, vice president with consultancy Economics Research Associates. "But once they're redeveloped there is an opportunity to attract the growing number of people who are frustrated with driving everywhere and want more pedestrian areas."

Turning the mall inside out

The Winter Park Mall in Winter Park, Fla., was a classic case of a dying mall. The 400,000-square-foot mall was located in the heart of the city's downtown. But with all of its stores facing in and a huge parking lot surrounding it like a moat, it was completely isolated from the rest of the town. As the nearby downtown shopping district thrived, the mall failed.

In the late 1990s, a new owner, the city and local business started making plans to break up the mall. Several phases into its makeover, Winter Park Village, as it's now called, is not unlike its surrounding downtown, with apartments, restaurants, a fitness center, a movie theater, a supermarket, office space and, of course, retail.

There are similar examples from across the country. Since local governments are loath to see a mall go belly up because it represents a huge loss of tax revenue, many are teaming up with developers to make sure the space is put to the best use possible.

"You're talking hundreds of thousands of acres of land that should be redeveloped," said real estate developer Will Fleissig, co-founder and partner with Continuum Partners. "Doing nothing with them is not an option."

Lakewood, Colo., for one, is playing a large role in the redevelopment of Villa Italia, which was the largest mall west of Chicago when it was built in the 1960s. By the early 1990s, however, it became clear that the 100-acre dinosaur could not compete with the area's newer malls, in part because it was not near a freeway interchange and did not have the space to surround itself with big-box stores.

In 2001, most of the mall was demolished to make way for Belmar, a mixed-use development that will have less retail space but nearly double the square footage. When complete, Belmar will be an extension of Lakewood's downtown, linked with city streets, bike paths and walking paths.

And by putting housing, entertainment, office space and parks into the mix, developers are creating demand for their retail tenants. Even if you don't plan to go on a full-blown shopping spree, you might just pop into the Gap for a new sweater while on your way to dinner or a movie. Or so they hope.  Top of page

  More on YOUR HOME
KB Home revamps dispute policy
Malls: Death of an American icon
Make your house your home
The best American cars
5 steps to financial independence
Drive-in movies: Still playing

graphic graphic

 CNNmoney contact us | magazine customer service | site map | CNN/Money glossary | press room
  OTHER NEWS: CNN | SI | Fortune | Business 2.0 | Time
2003 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. An AOL Time Warner Company ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Terms under which this service is provided to you. privacy policy  Reprints of site stories are available.