Jack Thomas' Commentary:

Revised June 12, 2009

Just to give the brief history that was slightly touched upon in Pete's commentary, the Penn Can Mall opened in 1975 by Rochester based Wilmorite, as an addition to the already exisiting Sears store on the property. Hills was later added on, and an addition in 1986 saw more stores and Syracuse based Chappell's brought in. Over time, other malls opened in the area, leaving this mall's customer base eroding away. Great Northern Mall came first in 1988, stealing Penn Can's Sears store, which was replaced with Steinbach, and later on, Burlington Coat Factory and Office Max. Then came Carousel Center opened in 1990, and the mall's fate was inevitably sealed. The mall was closed in 1994. Chappell's closed all of its locations soon after, and this one was swallowed up by Caldor, which was one of only several new stores built by the company before thier bankruptcy. And, when that came, this Caldor was closed and turned into one of the first signs of the property's future, a used car showroom. Hills, which became Ames in 1998, closed, and the rest of the mall followed. After a few years, local automotive entrepenuer Roger Burdick came to the rescue, purchasing the property.

I first visited Penn Can Mall, or what was left of it, on a trip to Syracuse in July of 2004. The mall has been converted into a huge automall called Drivers Village. The whole mall, save for the anchor spaces, the added on 1986 wing, the Sears auto center, and the outlot theater were demolished. The rest of the property was turned into auto dealers throughout. The interior of the remaining mall space has been turned into specialty shops, all related to the automotive nature of the property.

Subsequent visits over the years have seen the former Ames space remain vancant, even after serving as a used car showroom for some time, the demolition of the former theater for more dealers, the moving of Office Max to the neghboring and rejuvinated Marketplace Mall property, the never ending mutilation of the former Caldor space for more dealers, and most recently, the demolition of the former Sears auto center.

The mall is only a hint of it's former glorious self. The original flooring is all intact throughout the saved portion of the mall, and the once, if not still famous clock in the two level center court still greets shoppers, even though the shoppers' agendas have changed. It's still worth the visit though, just so you can get an idea of what the former premiere shopping destination in Syracuse was.

Pete Blackbird's Commentary:

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Syracuse is WAY overmalled. I think this may be due to the fact that Pyramid is located in Syracuse, and Wilmorite is located in nearby Rochester. Whatever the case may be, the result is a dead mall lovers paradise.

Penn-Can mall; this is the deadest of dead right here. It was so dead, I decided to apply for a job at it's Hills store, and it paid off. The Penn-Can mall was constructed in 1975, it was a 2 level mall, with lots of strong anchors, and it had a rather "modular" construction, which means that the anchors could be demolished and reconstructed with the needs of each particular store in mind. It started off life with Sears as it's sole anchor, and LOTS of small stores. Penn-Can was the first enclosed mall on the north side of syracuse, and remained the big dog until the early 90's, when the Carosel Center was constructed (a super-regional that boasts 3 levels of shopping). In 1983, Hills Dept store built onto the north side of the mall. In 1984 the Marketplace Mall built next door.

Marketplace proved to be no threat to Penn-Can, it was a smaller mall, with weak anchors, and never really got off the ground. At some point Sears decided to relocate thier store, and the space was filled with Burlington Coat factory, and Office Max. In 1992 a west wing and Caldor was added to the mall, and the whole shopping center was refaced internally. It was designed with an early American theme, which reassured the mall's position as top dog in North Syracuse. With the opening of Carousel Center, mall traffic dropped off sharply, and stores closed with an alarming fury. The mall went from hero to zero by 1996. Wilmorite didn't renew leases, and when the dust settled, the mall was borded up. The Caldor was included in a round of closings of it's central NY stores in 1997. A car dealership moved into this space, and the parkinglot became a pothole haven. In 1998 a funscape movie theater opened next to the Hills store, and in 1999 The Hills store was aquired by Ames.

The mall remained virtually empty, and with the boards up, the inside of the mall decayed. When I was employed at Hills, the mall changed hands, and the new owner of the mall hired a security gaurd to inhibit vandalism. I talked with her, and she showed me around the inside of the mall. The roof had leaked, and water damage was extensive, but the trees were still alive. The seats of the movie theater had been moved onto the second level of the mall, and there were dead rabbits and cats that had become trapped in the mall somehow. It smelled horrible, and there were wires running through the mall going to the different stores that remained opened. All of the store fronts were ones of traditional mall stores (ormond, anderson-little, charney's, lens crafters), which tells me that this mall went from hero to zero in a very short period of time. The mall has been re-boarded up recently, but other than that there hasn't been any changes to it. I recmomend a visit to this piece of retail history.

Exclusive Photos:

Click here for exclusive photos.

Links: Awesome fan site with many vintage 70's and 80's high quality scans of the inside and outside of the mall. I love the old cars, too!

Bing Bird's Eye View:

Penn-Can and Marketplace mall from a satellite in space
Translate Site

User comments (new!!)

(Please be respectful of other users, thanks! For a permanent essay post, please use this link.)

 Check out's Dead Malls Media archive!

Click here for books from Amazon about Retail and Malls!

Have information on this mall's history, current conditions, future plans, personal memories, corrections or general comments?

Please let us know using the contact form!

Thank you to all those who have contributed to! makes no guarantee of the completeness or accuracy of any information provided herein. You, the reader, assume the risk of verifying any materials used or relied on. is not liable for and does not necessarily endorse viewpoints expressed by the authors of content presented. Information is presented as a historical account and may not reflect present-day status. All submissions become property of and are posted at will. By using in any manner you understand and agree with these policies.

<--- Back to dead mall stories
<--- Back to main page
Deadmalls Search

©2000-2022 unless otherwise noted, All Rights Reserved.